A Journey with Ubuntu: Conclusion so far.

[Previous article of the Journey: A Journey With Ubuntu : Hardware Challange]

After giving Ubuntu a try for more than 2 months, was I able to achieve my goal?

A short answer is no. I eventually reverted to Windows XP. Let’s have a look why with more details.

What worked well while using Ubuntu ?

The interface is nice, pleasant to use, nice color and nice sound. I’m one of those that don’t waste time with themes, etc. So I keep default themes.

Using multiple workspace is very cool and turned to be very useful despite my initial skepticism.

The package updater is great. One point though, when you got an update you don’t know what the update are fixing, you just update from the repositories you have setup.

Boot time, shutdown time: Fine; nothing to be excited with: I does what it does in a reasonable time.

What did not worked while using Ubuntu ?

Some of my hardware components were not recognized at all : the internal microphone is certainly the most paintful one and in a lesser extend the finger print reader.

The falling sensor that can be used to protect my HDD didn’t have any drivers to be installed (as final/stable package).

The Wifi connection at boot time was rather erratic and slow to connect (when eventually it did). I had to wait frequently more than 2 minutes before being connected to Internet. When I open my machine only to check my emails, this is frustrating because I eventually spend more time trying to get this damned wireless connection working than checking and doing my emails.

Skype did not work correctly: the sound was awful and the phone calls were cut repeatedly not to mention the need to use my external microphone.

I needed to create “Word” document to be used by others and couldn’t fail to have the document layout and content not looking right. So using Open Office was not appropriate; I reverted back to XP to create these documents from Microsoft Office. I know this is not Ubuntu related but consider I had to revert back to XP to achieve my task. Some of you could point to Wine. Others could argue about installing virtual image of Windows and MSOffice, blablabla … STOP.  I aim simple install and straight forward usage or forget it. I’m not keen to go on the geek side just to be proud of doing it. What about MS Office supporting Ubuntu :-) kidding…. euh, actually …. not.

Side note about MS Office handcuffing: sadly when it turns to official document to exchange for business Word is still the standard de-facto.

I had to provide remote assistance to users that running XP and using TeamViewer Quick Support. Sadly Teamviewer is not Ubuntu supported and so I had to revert to XP during the remote assistance session. I know you could argue I just need to change to a new remote assistance tool. Ok, but give me one that is as easy and as intuitive as Teamviewer (from the remote controlled side percepective). One name and I’m ready to discuss and review the product.

Conclusion.

Using Ubuntu has been a very interesting experience and I discovered a world full of promises. Unfortunately it wasn’t able to fulfill all my needs. As my goal was to completely switch to Ubuntu, I must say this is not successfull and so I reverted to XP.

I will possibly give it a try again when the next release of Ubuntu is available. But not without having my internal microphone, finger print reader, falling detector working appropriately. If the hardware limitation are lifted up, I’ll be happy to go for a second journey.

Ok, I know, the case with MSOffice will not be resolved…but I might then be really tempted to switch away from Windows XP. I’m sure you, Ubuntu lover, will suggest me a replacement for Teamviewer.

Did I say Second Journey, already ?

A Journey With Ubuntu : Hardware challenge

[Previous article of the Journey: Installation and first impression]

When it comes to installing an OS on your machine, you expect to get the functionalities provided by your hardware translated into the OS. This statement is true for any OS, would it be XP, Vista, Ubuntu, or something else.

My laptop is a Thinkpad R61i 8932-GNG (full hardware details here)

What worked by default after the install:

  • Wifi : although the wifi light is not working.
  • Sound (althought the loudness seems lower than when running with Windows XP
  • 4in1 integrated card reader (at least for SD cards)
  • Webcam and its led indicator
  • Mute, volume up and down buttons
  • Lock fn key (Fn+F2)
  • Battery fn key (Fn+F3): it pops up Power Information infobox
  • Suspend fn key (Fn+F4) : although when it returns from suspend mode the brightness is set to max.
  • Radio fn key for wifi/bluetooth(Fn+F5) : it cycle thought different state wifi=on+bt=off, wifi=on+bt=on, wifi=off+bt=on, wifi=off+bt=off
  • Easy eject fn key (Fn+F9)
  • Brightness fn keys (Fn+Home and Fn+End)
  • Thinklight fn key (Fn+PgUp)

What I did not tested:

  • Network connection (RJ-45).
  • Modem (RJ-11).
  • Fluetooth.
  • Firewire.
  • Connecting an external screen and the screen switcher fn key (Fn F7).
  • S-video connector.
  • Expension slot (for docking).
  • PCI slots.

What doesn’t work :

  • ThinkVantage button : nothing associated to it.
  • integrated fingerprint reader.
  • Integrated microphone : IntMic is link to the external Mic connector.
  • Ultranav/touchpad fn key (Fn+F8).
  • multimedia fn keys (fn+Up, Fn+Down, fn+Left, fn+Right).
  • magnifier fn keys (Fn+Space).
  • The Lenovo Active Protection System:  it seems that API exists with “ugly packages” to handle the info generated by the accelerometer but nothing for bundling the accelerometer and locking the heads of the HDD. I guess this will come…. one day.
  • The Fan is always on: not that it isn’t working but I would expect it to work only when the heat of the system requires it and so provide a quieter machine with longer autonomy.

What worked but after some tweaking or manual steps

  • special keys next to the arrow keys : they needed to be configured.
  • Euro sign : I had to configure it in the Keyboard preferences.

Other aspects:

  • The Autonomy also is surprisingly small that with XP. I guess that the driver for the processor on XP are better and so consume less power when you try to max out the autonomy of the laptop.

In Conclusion : Is the hardware support a success for my case ? Yes about right. The peace that really lacks is the internal microphone. The Fan is annoying for the noice and the reduced autonomy is slighly disappointing. I feel also bizarre for the APS and the fingerprint reader but they are not going to ruin my experience with Ubuntu.

I haven’t given up yet with the non-working internal microphone but at the time of the writing this is still an open issue. It looks like there is not solution for having the internal microphone working with Ubuntu 8.04. 1 word come to my mind: disappointed.

I hope that with time fingerprint reader and APS will be supported on my machine.

A Journey with Ubuntu : Installation and first impression.

[Previous article of the Journey : The trigger and the goal]

I eventually decided myself to install Ubuntu, but the key point is: I want to keep my laptop with XP because I have installed the softwares that support my needs. I don’t want to play with partition resizing and all the likes to install Ubuntu, nor to start from zero with only an Ubuntu installation.

Wubi is then a great tool from me.

Downloaded from www.wubi-installer.org, I started the installation of Ubuntu 8.04 via Wubi directly from XP. Dead easy: 1 screen to define where to install Ubuntu, the size of the Ubuntu partition, a username and a password. Click on Install. The download of Ubuntu installation files starts. You can go away and relax. When downloaded, Ubuntu installs by itself without any user intervention. I did not recorded how long it took for the installation itself but I recall it wasn’t long at all.

Ubuntu Desktop Screen

Ubuntu Boot Screen

My laptop now prompts with a boot menu: XP or Ubuntu, defaulting after 15 sec to XP. First boot on Ubuntu. Right after the boot menu, a nice boot screen appears: graphical, sober. This welcomes the user for more.

It leads with sound to a login screen asking for my username, then to a second screen asking my password. Being very used to Windows this is bizarre not having the username and the password on the same screen. But it provides the same usability as it would be if on the same screeen. Different road goes Rome.

Ubuntu Desktop

Ubuntu Desktop

Rapidly I arrive to the desktop of Ubuntu with a tadaa-like sound. Nice default theme, warm and welcoming colors.Curiosity guides me. There are 2 panels. I find bizarre having the menu on the top; yet again my Windows habbits are in conflict with what I see. But hey I’m here to break through barriers!

I go over what is installed by default… OpenOffice, Firefox, Pidgin, Movie Player, Brasero to burn CD/DVDs, a bunch of Accessories, some small games and a couple of others apps. some default graphical tools. I’m not trying to be exhaustive, This is not my aim, but these were what catched my eyes.

I then configured the wireless on my laptop. It could have been smoother but eventually I got connected to the Internet.

All of this is subjective of course but still important. First impression is very important. Just like with meeting someone. first sight and handshake are key and drive a lot later.

First handshake with Ubuntu is a success. I want more.

[Next article of the Journey: A Journey With Ubuntu : Hardware challenge]

A journey with Ubuntu : the trigger and the goal

Ubuntu Logo

I decided to start using Ubuntu on my machine. Why ? Good question. Curiosity I guess. I had the idea to test it with my previous machine already but didn’t make it. I recently bought a new laptop and I decided that it would be a false good reason to start the journey with Ubuntu.

Ubuntu came to my ears through a colleague. He showed me a couple of screens on his machine, etc. I shared my interest about exploring Ubuntu some when in the future. He eventually told me about Wubi, a simple way to install Ubuntu from XP. I guess the possibility to experience Ubuntu without breaking my daily usage needs on XP was the trigger to enter to the Journey.

Thanks Georges for enabling the start of my Journey with Ubuntu.

I need a goal for exploring (adopting?) Ubuntu.

Let’s define what I do with my Computer at home so far using XP and various softwares :

  • Webmail, Instant Messaging and surfing on the internet, blogging.
  • Creation of document (word like, excel like) although Google Docs responds to some needs.
  • Viewing, basic editing and printing pictures imported from my digital camera: I use Picasa.
  • Phone call and video call with friends and family : I use Skype.
  • Viewing and simple editing of videos sequences imported from my digital videocam: I use the default tools that come with my videocam and VLC.
  • few listening of music or watching of DVD films : I use Windows Media Player.
  • Burning CDs or DVDs with my data (pictures and videos).
  • Transferring CDs to my MP3 portable player.
  • Helping friends and family with Desktop Remote Control tool ( I use Teamviewer).
  • Backup solution for my data: I use Mozy

    The goal for my Journey with Ubuntu will be to create an operational environment on my laptop that can support all those needs. Despite having an IT background, I’m not willing to enter into complex solving at home. It will have to be basic and straightforward.

    I plan to post various posts on this blog that will highlight my journey with Ubuntu.

    Stay tuned.

    If you have ideas or tips for helping my Journey, I welcome your input.

    [Next article of the Journey: Installation and first impression.]

    Posted in Ubuntu. Tags: . 1 Comment »